Pancytopenia: A
multidisciplinary assessment of hemato-etiological and clinical spectrum in a
tertiary care hospital
Katti T.V.1 Shankar A.A.2, Patil
T.3, Seshagiri K.S.4
1Dr. Trupti Vyasrao Katti, Professor,
2Dr. Anand Anantharao Shankar, Professor & HOD, 3Dr. Tejeshwini
Patil, Assistant Professor, 4Dr. Sangeeta Seshagiri K., Third
year Post Graduate Student, all authors are affiliated with Department of
Pathology, Navodaya Medical College, Raichur, Karnataka, India
Corresponding Author: Dr. Anand A.S, Professor & HOD, Department
of Pathology, Navodaya Medical College, Raichur, Karnataka, India, Email: asanand27@gmail.com
Abstract
Background: The causes of pancytopenia range from simple, completely
treatable diseases to serious life-threatening conditions. A thorough
evaluation of these cases is mandatory as it would benefit the patients to
receive appropriate treatment. Objectives:
Evaluation of etio-hematological and clinical spectrum of pancytopenia. Settings and Design: A prospective
study of two years (Jan 2016 -December 2017) was conducted on pancytopenic
patients, attending Navodaya Medical College, Hospital and Research Centre,
Raichur, Karnataka. Material and Methods: Etio- hematological and
clinical evaluation was done considering the relevant biochemical and
serological investigations. Results:
A total number of 1368 cases were diagnosed as pancytopenia. The patients’ age
ranged from 19 to 68 years and M: F ratio was 2.1:1. Most frequent clinical
symptom was generalized weakness (90%) and least was bony pain (2%). Peripheral
smear examination revealed predominantly macrocytic blood picture (47.9%). Bone
marrow aspiration was performed in 444 cases (32.4%), among which Megaloblastic
anaemia (Exclusive and Combined with iron deficiency anemia) was the commonest
(52.7%). Etiologies of pancytopenia in decreasing order of frequency included Megaloblastic
anemia {935 cases (68.4%) – Exclusive type (713 cases; 52.2%) and Combined with
iron deficiency anemia (222 cases ;16.2%), followed by Dengue fever (141 cases
;10.3%), Hypoplastic/Aplastic anemia [106 cases ;7.8% (Drug induced - 4 cases;
0.2%)], Septicemia (60 cases ;4.5%), Leukemia (46 cases ;3.25%), Chronic
malaria (46 cases ;3.25%) and Myelodysplastic syndrome (34 cases; 2.5%). Conclusion: Keeping in mind varied
etiologies of pancytopenia, thorough diagnostic evaluation is required to
achieve better clinical outcome.
Keywords: Clinical spectrum, Etio-hematological profile, Pancytopenia, Serological
and Biochemical investigations.
Author Corrected: 20th June 2018 Accepted for Publication: 23rd June 2018
Introduction
Pancytopenia is an
important commonly encountered hematological condition characterized by a triad of findings that results from a number of
disease processes - primarily or secondarily involving the bone marrow leading
to decrease in all three lineages of blood cells [1]. The underlying
mechanisms other than decrease in hematopoietic cell production are marrow
replacement by abnormal cells, suppression of marrow growth and
differentiation, ineffective hematopoesis, defective stem cell formation,
antibody mediated sequestration, destruction and trapping of cells in an
overactive reticuloendothelial system [2, 3].
Etiologies of this
condition can be due to common diseases like nutritional anemias, drug induced
myelosuppression and infections such as malaria, kala azar or dengue, to life
threatening conditions like aplasia, myelodysplasias and leukemias [4]. The
prevalence and risk factors vary in different geographical areas depending on
life style, nutritional status and exposure to chemical or biological
myelotoxins. A wide range of clinical and hematological manifestations are
exhibited due to broad spectrum of etiologies of pancytopenia. An early
detection of underlying pathology helps in timely diagnosis and therapeutic
intervention favoring a better clinical outcome [5, 6].
Hence, this study was thus
undertaken to evaluate cases of pancytopenia in Raichur, Karnataka state.
Objectives
1. Evaluation of
hemato-etiological and
2. Clinical spectrum of
cases of pancytopenia
Materials
and Methods
Place and type of study- This prospective study of 2 years
(January 2016-December 2017) comprised of 1368 cases of pancytopenia who
attended Navodaya Medical College, Hospital & Research Centre, Raichur,
Karnataka. A detailed analysis of hematological, different etiologies and
clinical findings were done.
Sampling methods and sample collection- A thorough clinical
history was taken along with general and systemic examination of patients.
Various hematological and serological parameters were analyzed and are as
follows:
i) Hematology- Using semi automated hematology analyzer
Pentra ES 60, CBC (Hb%, red cell indices, total and differential leucocyte
count, platelet count) along with grading of anemia, leucopenia and
thrombocytopenia was done, while peripheral smear study by Leishman stained
blood smears.
Features observed in the latter were:
RBC-Anisopoikilocytosis, nucleated RBCs and morphological type of anemia; WBC -
Hypersegmented neutrophils, toxic granulation, relative lymphocytosis and
immature cells/ blasts; Platelets- Normal, small & giant forms and screening
for hemoparasites. Reticulocyte count was estimated on New Methylene Blue
stained smears. Bone marrow aspiration was performed wherever feasible after
obtaining written consent from the patients. The procedure was done using Salah
needle, the aspirate obtained was spread on the glass slides which were
subsequently stained by Leishman’s & Giemsa stain and observed for cellularity,
myeloid: erythroid (M:E) ratio, erythropoiesis, myelopoiesis, megakaryopoiesis,
lymphocytes, plasma cells, bacteria/parasites/fungal elements, blast cells and
other infiltrative disorders. Blasts were categorised as per WHO and FAB
classification and criteria. Special stains with Myeloperoxidase (MPO) and
Periodic acid Schiff reagent (PAS) were done on peripheral smears & bone
marrow smears, wherever required.
ii) Relevant biochemical investigations included serum iron,
ferritin, Vitamin B12 & folate studies and c-reactive protein (CRP).
iii) Serological tests with Rapid Card Malaria test and
Dengue card test (NS1, IgM and IgG) were performed in suspected cases.
Inclusion criteria
Patients between
18-70 years of age whose hemoglobin
values recorded < 12 gm/dl (in males) and < 11 gm/dl (in females) respectively,
total leucocyte count < 4000/mm3 and platelet count < 1.5
lakh/mm3 (As per WHO guidelines).
Exclusion criteria
1. Patients <18
years and > 70 years of age.
2. Those cases who
received whole blood or component therapy.
3. Patients on
chemotherapy or radiotherapy.
Results
A total number of 1368
cases were diagnosed as pancytopenia. Age of cases ranged from 19 to 68 years,
maximum (74%) were in 41-50 years age group, males (68%) outnumbered females
(32%) and M: F ratio was 2.1:1.
Among clinical features,
generalized weakness (1231 cases; 90%) was most common, while bony pain (27
cases; 2%) was least common (Refer table 1).
Table-1: Overall distribution of clinical features in
pancytopenic cases
Clinical Features |
No. of cases |
Percentage (%) |
Generalized weakness |
1231 |
90 |
Pallor |
903 |
66 |
Dyspnoea |
684 |
50 |
Fever |
300 |
22 |
Bleeding Manifestations |
82 |
6 |
Jaundice |
68 |
5 |
Splenomegaly |
287 |
21 |
Hepatomegaly |
123 |
9 |
Lymphadenopathy |
41 |
3 |
Bony Pain |
27 |
2 |
Hematological findings: i) Hemoglobin values varied from 2.6
to 8.4 gm%, mean corpuscular volume(MCV) from 48.2 to 110.5 fl, mean
corpuscular hemoglobin (MCH) from 14 to 35.2 pg/ml and mean corpuscular
hemoglobin concentration (MCHC) from 0.5 to 46 gm/dl. Leucocyte count ranged
from 500 to 3600/ mm3, while platelet count from 12,000 to
1,20,000/mm3. Range of blood cell parameters observed is illustrated
in table 2.
Table-2: Distribution of hematological parameters
Parameters |
Range |
Present study |
Hemoglobin (gm %) |
1.5- 5 |
246 (18%) |
|
5-8 |
958 (70%) |
|
>8 |
164 (12%) |
Total leucocyte count
(cells/mm3 ) |
500-1000 |
109 (8%) |
|
1001-2500 |
533 (39%) |
|
2501-3900 |
725 (53%) |
Platelet count(cells/mm3) |
10k-50k |
259 (19%) |
|
50k-1lakh |
656 (48%) |
|
1lakh-1.5 lakh |
451 (33%) |
ii) On peripheral smear
examination, varying degree of anisopoikilocytosis was observed, predominantly
tear drop cells followed by target cells, schistocytes, microspherocytes and few
cases (6.3%) showed nucleated RBCs. Morphologically,
macrocytic anemia (656 cases; 47.9%) was commonest (Fig 1) , followed by
dimorphic (478 cases; 34.9%), microcytic hypochromic (179 cases;13.1%) and
normocytic normochromic (55 cases; 4.1%) blood picture (Fig 2). Hyper segmented
neutrophils were seen in 586 cases (42.8 %), toxic granulation in 80 cases (5.8
%) and relative lymphocytosis was noted in 309 cases (22.6 %). Few patients (46
cases; 3.3 %) showed blasts of either myeloid or lymphoid lineage. Ratio of platelet
morphologies were giant: small: normal as 2.3:1: 9.6. Hemoparasites were seen
in 46 cases out of 1368 cases (2.7 %), where Plasmodium falciparum (36 cases;
78.2%) was more frequent (Fig 4) compared to Plasmodium vivax (10 cases; 21.8%).
iii) Reticulocyte count
was normal in 48%, increased in 32% and decreased in 20% of cases.
iv) Bone marrow aspiration
was performed in 444 cases ; those with hypercellularity (316 cases; 71.2%) was
most common, followed by hypocellular (105 cases; 23.6%) and normocellular
marrow (23 cases; 5.2%).
Fig-1: Peripheral smear showing
macrocytic blood picture with segmented neutrophil (5 lobes) (Leishman’s stain
x400), with inset of bone marrow aspiration showing megaloblastic erythropoiesis (Leishman’s stain x400).
Fig-2: Peripheral smear showing normocytic normochromic
blood picture ( Leishman’s stain x400) with inset of bone marrow aspiration
showing aplastic marrow with increased fat (Leishman’s stain x400).
Fig-3: Peripheral smear showing Pelger Huet anomaly ( Leishman’s
stain x400), with inset of bone marrow aspiration showing dysmyelopoiesis
(Leishman’s stain x400).
Fig-4: Peripheral smear showing gametocyte form of
Plasmodium falciparum (Leishman’s stain x400) with inset showing schizont forms
of Plasmodium vivax (Leishman’s stain x400).
Among the morphological
categories of marrow, exclusive megaloblastic erythropoiesis (152 cases; 34.2%)
was most frequent (Fig 1), followed by aplasia (105 cases; 23.6%) (Fig 2),
combined megaloblastic and micronormoblastic erythroid hyperplasia (82 cases;
18.5%), leukemia (46 cases; 10.4%), myelodysplasia (35 cases;7.9%) (Fig 3) and
normoblastic erythropoiesis (24 cases; 5.4%). No hemoparasites/ granulomas
/parasites /fungal elements were noted. The most common etiology was
megaloblastic anemias [935 cases; 68.4% - exclusive (713 cases; 52.2%) and combined
with iron deficiency anemia (222 cases; 16.2%)], while the least common cause
was myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS- 34 cases; 2.5%) (Refer table 3).
Table-3: Distribution of spectrum of etiologies of
pancytopenic cases
Etiologies |
No of cases |
Percentage (%) |
Megaloblastic anaemia (with and without micronormoblastic
erythroid hyperplasia) |
935 |
68.4 |
Dengue fever |
141 |
10.3 |
Hypoplastic/Aplastic
anaemia |
106 |
7.8 |
Leukemia |
46 |
3.2 |
Myelodysplastic syndrome |
34 |
2.5 |
Septicemia |
60 |
4.5 |
Malaria |
46 |
3.2 |
Others |
- |
- |
Four cases were drug
induced where two patients diagnosed as rheumatoid arthritis were on gold
treatment , one with bronchial asthma and one with SLE were on steroid therapy
.Out of total leukemic cases, 38 were AML M2 (82.6%) and 8 were ALL L1 (17.4%).
All etiological categories
presented with symptoms like generalised weakness, pallor, dyspnoea and fever,
while petechiae was noted in cases with dengue and leukemia. Patients with
malaria, dengue and drug induced aplastic anemia presented with jaundice;
whereas two cases of leukemia (AML M2) had bony tenderness. Clinically,
splenomegaly was observed in 425 cases (45.5%) of megaloblastic anemia, 30
cases of malaria (65.2%), 24 cases of leukemia (52.2%) and 20 cases of MDS
(58.8%); whereas hepatomegaly was more predominat in leukemia (26.1%), followed
by MDS (23.5%) and megaloblastic anemia (22.2%). Lymphadenopathy was present in
56 cases (5.9%) of megaloblastic anemia, all the 28 cases (100%) of aplastic
anemia and 10 cases (21.7%) of leukemias respectively.
Hematological variations in different
etiological groups:
i) CBC: Majority of cases showed moderate anemia (70%), followed by
severe (18%) and mild degree (12%). Cases with high MCV values were more common
(60%) in this study and belonged to nutritional anemia category, followed by
low values (22%) which were observed in malaria and septicemia; while normal
range was noted in rest of the cases (18%). MCH and MCHC were variably low
among all cases. Majority of cases had mild leucopenia (53%), followed by
moderate (39%) and severe (8%). Mild thrombocytopenia was observed in 33%,
moderate in 48% and severe in 19% of cases.
ii) Peripheral smear: Anisopoikilocytosis was most commonly seen in cases
of megaloblastic anemia (76%) compared to aplastic anemias (10%), leukemias
(4%) and MDS (2%). Microcytes, schistocytes and target cells were observed
mainly in cases of septicemia (5%) and rarely in patients with malaria and MDS
(2% each). Presence of nucleated RBCs was mostly observed in MDS (20%),
followed by malaria (11%), megaloblastic anemias combined with iron deficiency
anemia (8%) and leukemia [AML M2 (1%)].
The toxic granulation in neutrophils and shift to left in myeloid series
were noted in septicemia cases (65%), and hypersegmented neutrophils were
observed in cases with megaloblastic anemia (62%). Presence of blasts was
predominant in leukemia (46 cases; 57.5%) compared to MDS (34 cases; 42.5%).
Immature lymphoid cells were most commonly found in cases of aplastic anemia (95%),
followed by megaloblastic anemia (22%) and MDS (12%). Peripheral smear study showed
classical features of blasts of respective leukemias and were confirmed using
special stains. Giant forms of platelets were mostly seen in patients with
nutritional anemia (25%), compared to septicemia (8%) and dengue cases (6%),
while smaller forms were observed in aplastic anemias and rest other cases
showed normal platelets.
iii) Reticulocyte count: Increased count was observed in malaria,
nutritional anemia and septicemic cases, whereas those with aplastic anemia and
MDS showed reduced reticulocyte count.
iv) Bone marrow study: Varying degrees of dysmyelopoiesis was observed
and was most predominant in MDS (98%) followed by megaloblastic anemias (86%).
Discussion
The demographic pattern of
pancytopenia varies all over the world possibly due to the differences in
methodology, stringent diagnostic criteria, duration of study, geographic
distribution, genetic differences, age distribution, nutritional status,
infections and exposure to myelotoxic agents [7].
In present study, maximum cases of pancytopenia (74%) were observed in
41-50 years age group, which corroborated with the study of Shane et al (30 -55
years ;70%), while Anita Javalgi et al documented higher proportion in 15-25
years( 39.6%) [6,8]. M:F ratio of this study (2.1:1) was in accordance with
Lakey et al (2.6:1), while there was decline in the ratio in the studies
conducted by Gayatri et al (1.2:1) and Anita Javalgi et al (1.35:1) [4,6,9]. Majority
of the cases presented with weakness/ fatigue (90%) followed by pallor (66%)
and dyspnoea (50%), while a small proportion of patients had bleeding
manifestations (6%). Symptoms attributable to anemia or thrombocytopenia were more
common in this study than those due to leucopenia. Similar observation was documented
by Anita Javalgi et al [6]. Presentation of organomegaly {splenomegaly
(21%), hepatomegaly (9%) and lymphadenopathy (3%)} and bony tenderness (2%) was
comparable to those of Gayatri et al, Khunger et al, Khodke et al and Anita et
al [4,5,6,10].
Hematology
i) CBC- The variations in
hemoglobin value, leucocyte count and platelet count in this study were
comparable to other authors’ studies (Refer table 4).
Table-4: Comparison of blood cell parameters
Parameters |
Range |
Anita
Javalgi et al [6] (2013) |
GPK Reddy
et al [11] (2016) |
Present
study |
Hemoglobin (gm %) |
1.5- 5 |
32(30.18%) |
17(40.5%) |
246 (18%) |
5-8 |
58(54.71%) |
14(38.1%) |
958 (70%) |
|
>8 |
16(15.09%) |
9 (21.4%) |
164 (12%) |
|
Total leucocyte count (cells/mm3) |
500-1000 |
5(4.71%) |
3(7.1%) |
109 (8%) |
1001-2500 |
23(21.69%) |
22(52.4%) |
533 (39%) |
|
2501-3900 |
78(7.58%) |
17(40.5%) |
725 ( 53%) |
|
Platelet count(cells/mm3) |
10k-50k |
27(25.47%) |
22(52.4%) |
259 (19%) |
50k-1lac |
35(33.08%) |
9(21.4%) |
656 (48%) |
|
1lac-1.5 lac |
44(41.50%) |
11(26.2%) |
451 (33%) |
The variations in the red
cell indices (MCV, MCH and MCHC) were in accordance with the study of Nazish
Shinwari et al [12].
ii) Peripheal smear
findings: Anisopoikilocytosis was observed most commonly in megaloblastic
anemias (76% cases), followed by hypoplastic/aplastic anemias (10%), leukemias
(5%) and MDS cases (1%). Similar findings were noted by Gayatri et al and
Khunger et al [4, 10] (Refer table 5).
Among the peripheral
smear findings, macrocytic (48%) was the commonest which was in accordance with
Sweta et al (49%), whereas Gayatri et al reported dimorphic anemias (37.5
%) as predominant type [4,13]. The least common blood picture was normocytic
normochromic (4%) in this study, while Sweta et al documented dimorphic blood
picture as the lowest proportion (9%) [13].
Nucleated RBCs were
predominantly seen in cases of MDS followed by malaria in present study, while
Khunger et al and Gayatri et al noted them mostly in MDS and leukemic cases [4,
10]. Hypersegmented neutrophils were observed in 46.6% of total cases, whereas
Tilak et al documented them in 84.9% of cases, on the contrary Khunger et al
didn’t document in any case of pancytopenia [10,14]. Immature WBCs were more
commonly seen in cases diagnosed with leukemias, followed by MDS and
megaloblastic anemias which was comparable to the studies of Khunger et al and
Gayatri et al [4, 10]. Majority of cases of hypoplastic / aplastic anemia (95%)
had relative lymphocytosis whereas Tilak et al and Khunger et al reported lower
percentage ( 50% and 85.71%)[10, 14].
There are limited number
of studies in literature regarding platelet morphology in cases of
pancytopenia. Hemoparasite induced pancytopenia was documented in 46 cases (3.25%),
where all were diagnosed as malaria – i) On peripheral smear examination ( 38
cases), among which gametocytes of P. falciparum were detected in 28 cases while
gametocyte, trophozoite and schizont forms of P. Vivax in 10 cases and ii) By
Rapid card test in 8 cases which included P. falciparum in 5 cases and P. vivax
in 3 cases. Similar study by Gayatri et al documented malaria in 1.9% of cases
and noted gametocytes of P. falciparum on peripheral smear examination, while
Anita Javalgi et al observed the same in 3.7% of cases on both peripheral smear
and BMA smears; whereas Tilak et al reported malaria in 3.8% and kala azar in
2.5% of cases in their studies [4, 6, 14].
The peripheral smear
findings with respect to etiologies were comparable with other studies [4, 10] (Refer
table5).
Table-5: Comparison of peripheral smear findings of
varied etiologies Study groups: (1) Khunger et al [10] (2002), (2) Gayatri et
al [4] (2011), (3) Present study (2016-2017)
Etiologies |
Anisopoikilocytosis |
Nucleated
RBC |
Hypersegmented
Neutrophils |
Immature
WBC |
Relative
Lymphocytosis |
||||||||||
|
1 |
2 |
3 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
Megal. A |
97.2% |
88.3% |
76% |
12.5% |
- |
8% |
- |
49.3% |
62% |
12.5% |
25.7% |
6% |
97.2% |
7.8% |
22% |
Aplastic A |
0.07% |
89.4% |
10% |
- |
- |
- |
- |
26.3% |
1% |
- |
- |
- |
85.7% |
52.6% |
95% |
MDS |
- |
- |
1% |
50% |
- |
20% |
25% |
- |
- |
75% |
- |
15% |
- |
- |
12% |
Leukemia |
0.1% |
25% |
5% |
40% |
25% |
1% |
40% |
- |
12% |
100% |
50% |
75% |
- |
- |
- |
Malaria |
- |
100% |
- |
- |
- |
11% |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
iii) Reticulocyte count
was normal in 650 cases (47.5%), high in 436 cases (31.9%) and low in 282 cases
(20.6%), whereas Gayatri et al documented normal values in 82 cases (77.4%) and
low count in 24 cases (22.6%) [4].
iv) Bone marrow: Pancytopenia
may be either due to cellular or hypocellular marrow, thus mandating the exploration
of various etiologies. Out of the cases in which bone marrow aspiration was
performed, hypercellularity
was more common (71.2 %) followed by hypocellular (23.6 %)
and normocellular appearance (5.2 %). This was
comparable to Anita et al, who documented hypercellular in 68.8%, hypocellular
in 16.2% and normocellular marrow in 15% of cases [6].
The morphological features
of bone marrow were comparable with other studies. (Refer Table 6).
Table-6: Comparison of marrow morphological categories
Marrow
picture |
Lakey et
al [9] (2010) |
Verma N et
al [ 15] (2012) |
Present
study |
1.Normocellular/ Normoblastic
erythroid hyperplasia |
18.5% |
18.1% |
5.4% |
2. Micronormoblastic and
Megaloblastic erythroid hyperplasia |
- |
- |
18.5% |
3.Megaloblastic erythroid
hyperplasia |
24.2% |
40.2% |
34.2% |
4. Leukemia |
20.3% |
- |
10.4% |
5.Myelodysplasia |
7.4% |
9.7% |
7.9% |
6.Hypoplastic/aplastic anemia |
29.6% |
26.3% |
23.6% |
7.Plasmacytosis |
- |
2.7% |
- |
8.Myelofibrosis |
- |
2.7% |
- |
Results of biochemical and
serological tests were in accordance with similar study by GPK Reddy et al [11].
Etiologies
Table-7: Comparison of percentage wise distribution of
etiologies
Etiologies |
Khunger et
al [10] (2002 ) |
Gayatri et
al [4] (2011) |
Shinwari et
al [12] (2012 ) |
Reddy GP
et al [11] ( 2016 ) |
Present study |
Megaloblastic anaemia ( with and without micronormoblastic
erythroid hyperplasia) |
72 |
74 |
27 |
38.1 |
68.4 |
Dengue fever |
- |
- |
- |
- |
10.3 |
Aplastic anaemia |
14 |
18 |
21 |
26.2 |
7.8 |
Leukemia |
5 |
3.5 |
23 |
9.5 |
3.2 |
Myelodysplastic syndrome |
2 |
3.5 |
1 |
- |
2.5 |
Septicemia |
- |
- |
2 |
2.4 |
4.5 |
Malaria |
1 |
1.7 |
- |
7.1 |
3.2 |
Others |
6 |
- |
26 |
16.7 |
- |
The incidence of megaloblastic
anemia in pancytopenic patients varies in literature from 0.8% to 32.26% [10]. Megaloblastic anaemia
was observed to be the commonest cause of pancytopenia (68.4%), which is in
accordance with similar studies by Khunger et al (72%), Tilak et al (64%) and Gayatri
et al (74%) [4,10,14]. Among these cases, exclusive category was more common (52.2%)
when compared to those combined with iron deficiency
anemia(16.2%). In a similar study by Nazish Shinwari et al, megaloblastic anemia was documented in
27% of total cases where exclusive (20%) was predominant followed by combined
category (7%) [12]. Hence there should be a periodical assessment to diagnose the
nutritional anemias considering the diverse ethnic populations, different
dietary habits and social customs in India [6, 10].
The second common etiological group was dengue (10.3%). This was
in contrast to other studies which documented aplastic anemia (Refer table 5). The higher incidence of dengue in this
region was likely due to lower socioeconomic status, poor sanitation, lack of
awareness about the spectrum of clinical manifestations and increasing
frequency of vague & non-specific symptoms.
The
incidence of aplastic/ hypoplastic anemia according to the
literature varies from 10% to 52.7% [4, 11]. The present study
reported the same as the third common cause (7.7%), whereas Gayatri et al
(18.26%) and Khunger et al (14%) reported as second common etiology [4, 10]. Aplastic/hypoplastic
anemia may be due to triggering of aberrant immune response by viral
infections, exposure to chemicals and drugs or endogenous antigens generated by
genetically altered bone marrow cells, leading to active destruction of blood
forming cells by lymphocytes [7, 10]. Drug induced aplastic anemia is commonly
seen in cases receiving therapy for rheumatoid arthritis, hyperthyroid
conditions, tuberculosis, convulsive disorders and various inflammatory disorders.
The outcome depends on: i) dose and duration of exposure and
ii) Susceptibility or idiosyncracy to the myelotoxin. These usually cause
mild reversible marrow suppression, but may occasionally progress to more
severe damage [16]. Present study reported four cases of drug induced aplastic
anemia accounting to 0.2% of total cases, among which two were on gold and two
on steroid therapies; while Tilak et al also documented four such cases in 5.1%
of pancytopenic patients among which, three were on chloramphenicol and one on
streptomycin. Verma Nidhi et al reported three cases accounting to 4.2% and all
were on chloramphenicol [14, 15].
Next common cause included leukemia which comprised of 46 cases, where 38
were AML M2 and 8 were ALL L1; whereas Gayatri et al reported 4 cases where
three were AML M2 and one was ALL L2 [4].
The least common etiologies were septicemia (4.5%) , malaria (3.25%) and
MDS (2.5%); while Reddy P et al documented septicemia in 2.4% and
malaria in 7.1% of cases, respectively [11]. The incidence of malaria in other
studies were : Khunger JM et al - 1%;
Tilak V et al -3.9% and Kumar R et al - 3% respectively [3,10,14]. MDS in this study was
detected in thirty four cases (2.5%) which was similar to Khunger et al (2%),
whereas Anita et al documented the same in 0.9% of total cases [6,10].
The clinical features of pancytopenic
cases considerably varied according to the spectrum of different etiologies.
However, cases presenting with organomegaly and lymphadenopathy were comparable
with the studies of Khunger et al and Gayatri et al [4, 10].
Clinical findings as per
etiologies were compared. In cases of megaloblastic anemia, splenomegaly was
more predominant in this study (45.4%) compared to Khunger et al (28.5%) and
Gayatri et al (27.7%), while hepatomegaly (22.2%) was in accordance with the said
authors’ studies (29.1% and 29.8%) and lymphadenopathy was more common in
present study (5.9%) compared to Khunger et al(0.6%) and Gayatri et al (3.8%)
[4, 9]
The present study had no
organomegaly in cases of aplastic anemia, whereas Gayatri et al documented both
splenomegaly (21%) and hepatomegaly (15.7%), while Khunger et al documented
only hepatomegaly (3.5%). Lymphadenopathy in this study was more common (26.4%)
compared to Gayatri et al (5.2%).
In cases diagnosed as
leukemia, Khunger et al documented higher incidence of splenomegaly (80%) and
hepatomegaly (100%) compared to the present study (52.1%; 25%) and Gayatri et
al (25%; 25%). Lymphadenopathy was observed more commonly in the study by
Khunger et al (60%) compared to present study (21.7%).
The cases of MDS showed
splenomegaly and hepatomegaly more frequently in the study of Khunger et al (75%
; 50%) when compared to present study (58.8% ;23.5%). Lymphadenopathy was not
seen in this study as well as the authors’ studies.
Cases of malaria had
splenomegaly more commonly in the studies of Khunger et al (100%) and Gayatri
et al (100%) compared to this study (65.2%), whereas hepatomegaly and
lymphadenopathy was not seen in either of the said studies[4,9].
Among the frequent
etiologies of pancytopenia in the world scenario, aplastic anemia is documented
to be the commonest especially in countries like Israel, Europe, Bangladesh and
India. Myelodysplastic syndrome and neoplastic diseases are the next common
ones in Israel & Europe, chronic malaria and kala azar in Bangladesh; while
on the contrary, it was megaloblastic anemia in India [5].
Conclusion
Keeping in mind the probable etiologies and large proportion of
pancytopenia being reversible, a thorough
evaluation is warranted to
identify the underlying pathology at the earliest, thus guiding
the clinicians to implement preventive strategies and help the patients in
achieving better clinical outcome.
Contribution
Details
Names of Authors |
Study Concept |
Design |
Acquisition of data |
Analysis & Interpretiation of
data |
Compiled literature sources |
Drafting the manuscript |
Checked References |
Critical Revision |
Dr. Trupti V Katti |
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
Dr. A.S. Anand |
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
ü
|
Dr. Tejeshwini Patil |
- |
ü
|
ü
|
- |
- |
- |
ü
|
ü
|
Dr. Sangeeta Seshagiri |
- |
- |
- |
- |
ü
|
- |
ü
|
- |
What this
study add to existing knowledge- Based on assimilation of data from previous studies and
current research, there exists an overlap of certain clinico-hematological findings. As etiological
spectrum of pancytopenia is varied and confounds the pathologists and
clinicians, routine along with bone marrow and etiological based laboratory
evaluation is warranted. The frequency of this hematological
condition Pancytopenia, is on the rise and hence needs global attention.
References
1. Kar M,
Ghosh A. Pancytopenia Journal. Indian Academy of Clinical Medicine 2002; 3:
29–341.
2. Firkin F, Chesterman C,
Penington D, Rush B. De Gruchy’s Clinical Hematology in Clinical Practice. 5th
Edition. London Blackwell Scientific Publications 1989; 119-36.
3. Kumar et al.
Pancytopenia - A 6 year study. J Assoc Physicians India 2001; 49: 1079-81.
4. Gayatri B N,
Satyanarayan K. Pancytopenia –A clinico-haematological study. Journal of
Laboratory physicians 2011; 3(1): 15-20.
5. Khodke K, Marwah S,
Buxi G, Yadav RB, Chaturvedi. Bone marrow examination in cases of pancytopenia.
J Academy Clin Med 2001; 2: 55-59.
6. Javalgi AP,
Dombale VD. Clinico – Hematological Analysis of Pancytopenia: A Bone Marrow
Study. National Journal of Laboratory Medicine Dec 2013; 2(4): 12-17.
7. Vaddatti T et al. Clinico-haematological profile of
Pancytopenia- A South Indian tertiary hospital experience. Indian Journal of Pathology and Oncology July
– September 2015; 2(3): 165-69.
8. Graham S, Marla NS, Fernandes H,
Jayaprakash CS. A clinico-hematological evaluation of pancytopenia in a
tertiary care hospital in South India. Muller Journal of Medical Sciences
and Research Jan - Jun 2015; 6(1): 5-9.
9. Lakhey A, Talwar OP,
Singh VK, KC Shiva Raj. Clinico-Hematological Study Of Pancytopenia. Journal of
Pathology of Nepal 2012; 2(3): 207-10.
10. Khunger JM, Arculselvi S, Sharma U, Ranga S, Talib H.
Pancytopenia- a clinico-haematological study of 200 cases. Indian J Pathol
Microbiol 2002; 45(3): 375-79.[pubmed]
11..Reddy GPK, Kande V, Rao M. Clinical
features and risk factors of pancytopenia: a study in a tertiary care hospital. International Journal of
Advances in Medicine Feb 2016; 3(1):
68-72.
12. Shinwari S, Raziq F, Khan K, Uppal FT,
Khan H. Pancytopenia: experience in a
teriary care hospital of Peshawar, Pakistan. Rawal Medical Journal Oct-Dec
2012; 37(4): 370-73.
13. Barik SS, Chandoke RK, Verma AK. A prospective clinico‑hematological study in 100 cases of
pancytopenia in capital city of India. Journal
of Applied Hematology April-June 2014; 5(2): 45-50.
14. Tilak V, Jain R. Pancytopenia-A clinicohematological
analysis of 77 cases. Indian J Pathol Mcrobiol 1992; 42(4): 339-404.[pubmed]
15.
Verma Nidhi , Malik Harsh , Sharma Veena K, Agarwal Anil. Etiology of Pancytopenia in and around Meerut. Journal of Advance Researches In Biological
Sciences 2012; 4(2): 145-51.
16. Mintzer DM, Billet SN
& Chamielewski L. Drug induced Hematologic Syndromes. Advances in
Hematology 2009; 1-11.[pubmed]